Amalfi is amazing, but most people already know that. This hotel, and Cetara in general, are fantastic for people who want to be on Amalfi, but have a more tranquil experience with less crowds.
The negative is less convenient options to restaurants and shops. Cetara is terrific little town a short, but somewhat adventurous, walk away.
I would absolutely recommend the hotel based on the location, staff, cleanliness and size of rooms, the hotel restaurant, and hotel beach.