We have been coming here for over two decades, so obviously love it. It is located out of town, and is relatively small, so is nice and quiet. There are evening shows, but they were over before we went to bed, so didn’t disturb us. The staff were without exception excellent. We are not “foodies” but enjoyed all the options (although as Americans, we have learned to pack extra chocolates when traveling out of the country!). Non-alcoholic beer was finally available! The best part is the snorkeling that is available right in front of the resort. Our diving company, Dive With Cristina, picked us up at the pier right by the breakfast buffet.
Potential negatives: it is out of town so you need a car or ride to go anywhere else. Currently (November 2024) the pools are closed for major renovations. A snorkeling tour was provided as compensation. We initially had no hot water in the shower but this was fixed. One elevator was out of service but we used the stairs anyway. The hotel is a little “tired” and could use some paint.
I had to think hard to come up with these “problems”. Over the decades, we have stayed at five other resorts on Cozumel or the Riviera Maya. This remains our favorite by far. I would go back today if I could.