We book a hotel in NYC every week. This hotel, while decent, is certainly not four star as rated. It was clean, but very tiny, more so than other NYC rooms, and certainly not an above grade experience. Average, three star would be accurate.
Two notable very weird things: There is a picture on the wall that, surprise!, slides away to reveal a glass window that let’s one peer into the bathroom! What kind of pervert thought this was a good idea? The bathroom itself was fine, although the door did not stay shut. No closet, just hooks on a wall.