I say this as an airline pilot who stays in hotels half the year, but this has been one of the more disappointing stays I’ve had in a while. Though the staff was nice, the hotel is just down from an outdoor club that will blast vibrating level music into your room until 3am. I’m usually not bothered by noise, I live in a major downtown and am a former New Yorker myself, but this was over the top. Also, don’t expect terminal pickup/drop off service with the shuttle. Extra time has to be accounted for due to the Neward airTrain being a mess.
Either way, if you see other hotels at a similar price, choose them.