Friendly staff, with a new manager who spent time with us at check-in and made us feel very welcome.
Richard
Richard (1 晚友伴旅程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
2/10 欠佳
2025 年 5 月 9 日
Avoid at all cost
On check in we found the ladies bathroom to be out of order indicating plumbing issues and the gents toilet had no working light, the staff would have known at this point that there were issues with the plumbing system and with running water but failed to advise us of this. Our first impression of the hotel was that we were unable to see out the filthy windows and the carpets on the stairs were threadbare and in need of replacement. On entering the room later that evening the strong smell was disgusting and the bathroom did not look as though it had been serviced. The shower was dirty and under the sink the door was hanging off indicating again problems with plumbing in the hotel. In the morning we went to shower and our suspicion of a plumbing issue became real, no hot water which is totally unacceptable, more alarming the hotel reception played this complaint down as if it was just the norm. I asked to speak with manager at reception and was advised it was the managers last day and there would be a new manager tomorrow. I felt secure in the knowledge I would be issued a full refund with having booked through Hotels.com however without the want of trying I have been advised that “as subject to the rules and restrictions of the vendor they do not have the authority to change or override their policies” I feel totally let down by Hotels.com as no refund will be given, over the years I have always used this company over any other.
Agnes
Agnes (1 晚家庭旅程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2025 年 4 月 8 日
真實旅客
1 晚行程
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
2/10 欠佳
2025 年 4 月 6 日
Mary
Mary (1 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
2/10 欠佳
2025 年 4 月 6 日
Not Rushing Back
The hotel room was dirty and dusty, with curtains hanging off the rail. Room was cramped with bathroom only 2 steps from bed. Toilet was dirty and shower had black mould on bottom and round ill-fitting door. Rest of the hotel was dated and dirty. We paid for 2 nights but left after one, cancelling breakfast also as we decided hygiene may be an issue in the kitchen, if rest of hotel was the standard.
Receptionist was pleasant enough but didn't ask why we were leaving early. We've stayed in a lot of hotels over the years and don't mind dated decor etc but the red line is cleanliness. The hotel is damaging Dunkeld's reputation as a charming, friendly little town. Melville Hotels need to have a good look at themselves.
Clarke
Clarke (2 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 11 月 16 日
Weekend Away
Great staff, meals were good as well with great parking
Martin
Martin (1 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 11 月 3 日
Property was run down. Room was comfortable but toilet did not flush, the seal on the shower was broken and the curtains did not cover the window. When we asked the noisy Halloween disco if they could go ish the music they insisted on continuing until after midnight even though there was nobody there.
Janine
Janine (2 晚友伴旅程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 11 月 2 日
Very old building and it was a little confusing trying to find the entrance. Room was on the top floor which was a bit difficult for my elderly father.
Tiffany
Tiffany (1 晚家庭旅程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
2/10 欠佳
2024 年 11 月 2 日
Natalia
Natalia (1 晚行程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 11 月 1 日
Lovely staff but hotel needs some investment
Jo
Jo (1 晚行程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 10 月 31 日
1 night stay
1 night stay on way home.Sadly quite typical of Scottish Hotels run down & shabby.Staff nice & food good .Bathroom small but clean shower door hanging off.Room very warm & window didn't open.
AGNES
AGNES (1 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 10 月 29 日
Old hotel, but charming. Has a lovely little bar and is in an excellent location for shops and restaurants.
Kelly
Kelly (1 晚行程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
10/10 完美
2024 年 10 月 20 日
kevin
kevin (2 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 10 月 17 日
Ghosts running amok
Liked the haunted room
David
David (1 晚商務旅程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 10 月 13 日
Danny
Danny (1 晚家庭旅程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 10 月 8 日
Gordon
Gordon (1 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 10 月 1 日
The hotel was conveniently located and clean. It was not easy to find staff to check in or get room supplies. The room was clean, but spare. No towel rack, no tissue, no pictures on walls. Lacked appeal. Seemed like a dorm room. Breakfast choices were plentiful and well prepared. Pub was cozy and convenient. Pub and dining staff were friendly and helpful.
Gregory
Gregory (2 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
2/10 欠佳
2024 年 9 月 29 日
Melvyn
Melvyn (2 晚浪漫旅程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 9 月 27 日
The heat didn't work in Unit 202. On the second day the lovely receptionist gave me a space heater. She was great, the best.
The two regulars in the bar area were awful. They were looking for fights. Big disappointment.
Great location and clean.
Internet worked great. Overall a nice stay.
Karl
Karl (2 晚行程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 9 月 27 日
Sinking ship
Hotel felt fairly dirty and run down, very under staffed. Room rate was expensive and didn’t include breakfast.
General feel was that the hotel has ‘given up on life’, is merely surviving on the over flow business they get during wedding season by charging ridiculous rates knowing people have little option.
The few staff that were there were very pleasant but sadly not enough to make me ever want to stay at this overpriced sinking ship again.
Gillian
Gillian (1 晚行程)
Hotels.com 真實旅客評價
8/10 很好
2024 年 9 月 25 日
Plenty to explore good for walks etc very friendly people x we ate out which was fantastic food x
kathleen
kathleen (1 晚家庭旅程)
Expedia 真實旅客評價
6/10 不錯
2024 年 9 月 15 日
Had an overall good stay at hotel with my one year old son. Just a beautiful location on the map and our favourite place to visit, Dunkeld. We were in the Annex which is just, well, one room and toilet/electric shower. My opinion would be a slight bit work needing done more to the decorative side of things. Staff were nice for basically 30seconds but that’s all I had to deal with them to be fair, but very nice overall.