We picked this resort because it had a private beach, is close to old town, and seemed to have nice rooms. When we got there, all of that was true. I realized Key West is a pretty expensive place to stay no matter where you go, but I expected the resort to be a little bit more polished. For example, the hallways paint job could be spruce up. One elevator was not working and the door of the elevator on the second floor had a big scrape on it like it needed to be repainted. However, housekeeping service was wonderful as was the service on the beach. Our beds were comfortable and the bathroom was clean. The patio glass sliding door was extremely heavy and nearly impossible to open, but the view overlooking the courtyard was very nice. So for every thing I have there was always a positive so I think it balances out evenly. It’s just a really pricey place.