Harbors Edge was perfect for us---no frills, (yes, WiFi and a coffee pot and fridge), but comfy, tidy and convenient. If you don't need a car on Madeline Island this is just a walk across the street to the ferry terminal. A block off the two main drags, it is convenient to restaurants and shopping. Best of all, quiet during tourist season with helpful staff. We will make it our place in Bayfield!