Hotels in Bay Shore

Bay Shore Bliss: Embrace Island Serenity and Coastal Adventures

Nestled along the picturesque South Shore of Long Island, Bay Shore, New York, is a charming coastal gem that invites visitors to unwind and explore. Renowned for its stunning marina and easy access to serene beaches, including the nearby Jones Beach, this vibrant town is perfect for sun-soaked days and sunset strolls. Enjoy fresh seafood at waterfront eateries, embark on boat tours to the captivating Fire Island, or take a leisurely walk along the scenic bayfront. With a blend of natural beauty and small-town charm, Bay Shore is a delightful escape for families, couples, and nature lovers alike. For the best hotel rates in Bay Shore and to enhance your stay, be sure to check out Hotels.com's Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window on travel.

Top locations to stay in Bay Shore

Bay Shore, New York, offers a variety of hotel accommodations to suit different preferences and budgets. From cozy motels to well-known hotel chains, visitors can find comfortable options for their stay. Popular choices include family-friendly inns and more upscale hotels, many conveniently located near attractions and transportation links. Whether you're seeking a relaxing getaway or a convenient base for exploring Long Island, Bay Shore has something to meet your needs. Here are some of the most popular hotels with our guests in Bay Shore:

1. Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse ComplexOpens in a new window: Located approximately 4.0 miles away from Bay Shore, Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex is a 3.0-star hotel ideal for business travelers. This property offers a range of business amenities including an accessible business center, conference space, and meeting rooms, ensuring a productive stay for those traveling for work.
2. The Fire Island Beach HouseOpens in a new window: The Fire Island Beach House is a 2.5-star hotel that provides direct access to the beach, making it perfect for those seeking adventure and family-friendly activities. The hotel features options for adventure sports nearby, such as bicycle rentals, skydiving, and hiking. Additionally, there are amenities designed for children, including pool gates and stair gates, ensuring a safe and enjoyable experience for families.
3. The Ocean Bay HouseOpens in a new window: The Ocean Bay House, a 3.5-star Bed & Breakfast, offers guests a delightful stay with free daily breakfast options, including continental choices. Located near various attractions like a boardwalk and entertainment district, guests can enjoy entertainment options such as Netflix and Hulu in their rooms. This hotel combines comfort with convenience, making it a great choice for travelers looking to explore the area.

Things to do in Bay Shore for first time

A visit to Bay Shore typically requires three days to fully enjoy its stunning beaches, tranquil marinas, and nearby islands. Travelers can indulge in activities like boating, wildlife watching, and dancing under the stars, making it a perfect getaway for nature lovers and adventure seekers alike. Here's a quick itinerary to make the most of your trip to Bay Shore:

• Day 1: Begin your adventure at Heckscher State Park, where you can explore the beautiful trails and enjoy the natural scenery. After a morning of hiking or picnicking, head over to Great South Bay, a perfect spot for some relaxing time by the water. Take a leisurely stroll along the shore or rent a kayak to explore the bay. Wrap up your day at Town Beach, where you can unwind with the sunset views, perhaps enjoying a beachside dinner or a bonfire with friends.
• Day 2: Start your day by taking the ferry to Ocean Beach, a charming beach community known for its sandy shores and vibrant atmosphere. Spend some time lounging on the beach or exploring the local shops. Next, visit the Cherry Grove Community House and Theatre, where you can catch a performance or enjoy a community event. Conclude your day at Sailors' Haven, where you can soak up the beauty of nature, maybe take a swim, or just relax on the beach as the sun sets.
• Day 3: Kick off your day at Lake Ronkonkoma, where you can enjoy a tranquil morning walk around the lake or try your hand at some fishing. Following your lakeside activities, make your way to Islip Town Beach for some sun and fun in the sand. Finish your trip with a visit to Oheka Castle, a stunning historic mansion where you can tour the elegant grounds and perhaps enjoy a meal at the castle’s restaurant, reflecting on the wonderful experiences you’ve had in Bay Shore.

5 tips to find a great Bay Shore hotel deal

1. Book for the cheapest times: The most budget-friendly time to visit Bay Shore is during January, February, and December, when hotel prices are at their lowest. For international travelers, booking your flight at least one month in advance can lead to significant savings. To truly experience the area's main attractions, a stay of at least 2-3 days is recommended. In Bay Shore, you can enjoy beautiful beaches and a charming marina, making it a great value for money destination for those looking to explore without breaking the bank.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: If you're looking for great last-minute deals to Bay Shore, Hotels.com is a fantastic booking site to explore. To uncover potential savings, head to the DealsOpens in a new window or Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window section, where you could find discounted rates on hotels as your travel date approaches. To enhance your chances of snagging a good deal, consider enabling email alerts or push notifications from Hotels.com, keeping you informed about flash sales and special promotions specifically for Bay Shore hotels. Don’t miss out on these opportunities to book your stay!
3. Be flexible with dates: Hotel prices can differ due to factors like the hotel's location, star rating, and the season. As a result, having some flexibility with your travel dates could help you save on hotel expenses in Bay Shore.
4. Consider your location: When booking on Hotels.com for your vacation, take your location into account. Staying closer to major attractions or city centers can offer convenience, but it usually tends to come with a higher price tag. For more affordable options, consider looking for hotels in less central areas or neighborhoods, striking a balance between cost and the ease of reaching the places you plan to visit.
5. Upgrade with One Key: Make your next reservation in Bay Shore and be a part of Hotels.com's free One Key program, which enables members to take advantage of reward points for hotel bookings. Progress through the tiers of Blue, Silver, Gold and Platinum to unlock advantages like room upgrades when available, discounted rates, and exclusive offers for members. Start earning reward points now.

What to eat in Bay Shore

Here are a few popular dining spots in Bay Shore, New York, United States of America:

• Verde Kitchen & Cocktails: This vibrant eatery emphasizes fresh, seasonal ingredients to create innovative dishes that reflect the rich culinary traditions of the region. With a menu that creatively blends classic flavors with modern techniques, Verde Kitchen & Cocktails offers a unique dining experience that's both exciting and memorable.
• Mulberry Street Bay Shore: Celebrated for its delicious Italian-American cuisine, this restaurant showcases local ingredients in its handcrafted pasta and traditional recipes. The menu features inventive twists on beloved classics, making it a perfect destination for those looking to savor authentic flavors with a contemporary flair.
• Aji 53: Specializing in sushi and Asian fusion, Aji 53 takes pride in its artistic presentation and use of fresh, local seafood. The diverse menu highlights the creativity of its chefs, offering a blend of traditional and modern dishes that celebrate the flavors of the East with a local touch.

Best time to go to Bay Shore

Bay Shore experiences its lowest average temperature in January, at 34.3°F (1.3°C), while July is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 75.2°F (24.0°C). December tends to be the wettest month. The peak travel months to visit Bay Shore are April, June, and July, which see a higher number of tourists. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, accompanied by light rainfall. In contrast, October to December are ideal if you're looking for a calmer vacation, marked by light rainfall and mostly sunny conditions.